Welcome to The Yoga Teacher Training Forum Archive - A Collection of Various Yoga Topics
The Forum is Now Closed and Will Remain as an Information Archive.
For New Updates and Conversations, We Now Have a Public Facebook Group Located Here
Please consider registering
August 15, 2015
Hello everyone :-)
I wonder if anyone is interested enough in this topic to explore it with me...
I agree with the common verdict by yogis that we, as humans, are highly susceptible to breathe incorrectly. My reason for this is; personal experience, and watching others learn to breathe evenly and deeply in yoga class and what a challenge this can present.
I am lucky to have a major yoga skeptic in my life, and he is often asking loads of questions that challenge the way I understand what I'm learning in Yoga. He is a scientist, and wants to know how we yogis have come to the conclusion that people in general are often breathing incorrectly.
I wonder if anyone knows of any good chapters in books, or any scientific studies that might simplify the explanation?
I think it's an interesting and perfectly valid question that may come up from beginners to a new class. Why should we ask them to change the way they breathe?
Personally, I trusted in my teachers and followed their advice on breathing and pranayama, and managed to reap the rewards of this. What about the more skeptical student who believes this to be simply placebo? How can we prove to the skeptic that our breathing is often incorrect?
I am looking into this whilst I complete my other essay questions, so if I find interesting information I will list it here. I hope there is someone out there who might add to this also!
So far I have learned from James Hewitt 'The Complete Book of Yoga' in Chapter VI "Yogic Breath Control", that the psychotherapist Reich discovered his neurotic patients had developed muscular blocks against expelling old air from their system. "There is no neurotic individual who is capable of exhaling in one breath, deeply and evenly." (Reich).
Does anyone else know of any experimental studies on breathing?
The following users say thank you to dasharadovanovic for this useful post:Dr. Paul Jerard, E-RYT 500
This is the tip of the iceberg, there are more studies.
Here's an Online Book
Full Catastrophe Living: Using the Wisdom of Your Body and Mind to Face ...
By Jon Kabat-Zinn, Thich Nhat Hanh
August 13, 2014
Thank you for bringing this up!
It is interesting to note that many of the scientific skeptics claim that they can't find proof of medical research about Yoga. Don't these same people use Google scholar for medical research on other topics? Don't they see the studies on the news?
It reminds me of the people who say they see no proof of global warming. I hope they don't own beachfront property.
The following users say thank you to Ishrattasleem for this useful post:Dr. Paul Jerard, E-RYT 500
Most Users Ever Online: 340
Currently Browsing this Page:
Yoga Paul: 138
Don Briskin: 69
Guest Posters: 43
Administrators: Meredith, Dr. Paul Jerard, E-RYT 500, Paul